: Eleganter Unsinn. () by Alan Sokal; Jean Bricmont and a great selection of similar New, Used and Collectible Books available. Results 1 – 14 of 14 Discover Book Depository’s huge selection of Alan-Sokal books online. Free delivery worldwide Eleganter Unsinn · Alan Sokal. Paperback. A review and a link to other reviews of Fashionable Nonsense by Alan Sokal and Authors: Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont Eleganter Unsinn – Deutschland.
|Published (Last):||1 November 2018|
|PDF File Size:||5.61 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||19.30 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Unlimited One-Day Delivery and more. To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number. Revealing the hoax, Sokal set off quite an uproar, only in part about the question he was addressing — the use of science and scientific concepts and terminology in a non-scientific setting.
Fashionable Nonsense is a perverse and maddening book. It is a problem society should wrestle with.
Long live logic, indeed. Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity which he describes as “a parody article crammed with nonsensical, but unfortunately authentic, quotations about physics and mathematics by prominent French and American intellectuals. Certainly all ways of looking at something should be considered, but equally certainly most like sexed relativity can be quickly dismissed.
The question is not completely black and white — of course relativism operates in many significant areas of human intercourse, including science — the question is in the how and where and of course the why.
The blanket relativism that Sokal offers in his parody is an absurdity, and easily recognizable as such. Our two cents re. Except for on a solal Star Trek episode we can’t see much use for considering the speed of light privileged. More plausible is the argument that Sokal and Bricmont only show a few selective examples, that these may or may not be representative, and that they often only figure in a small part of the cited authors’ works i.
And it doesn’t seem to fly, because these grand thinkers are all so damn ponderous and serious. Get to Know Us. We don’t really get that argument, but it is a fun idea.
The notorious parody written by Alan Sokal and published by a gullible gang of academics at Social Text is one of the sadder chapters in modern American academia. Worth leafing through, but unsijn to recommend actually reading it. Passages are cited and ridiculed, and Sokal and Bricmont then also make some larger and more general points. Would you like to tell us about a lower price? It is an unusual way of undermining science since the thinkers are toppled along with their false foundationsbut this, surely, is the unsihn dangerous aspect of the whole affair — that science is pulled down to their level, when its great value is in being above such petty and mindless debate, when its alwn is in the intellectual rigor it demands.
Intends show that from a similar case, similar conclusions can be drawn.
The shoddily edited Social Text — its editors perhaps so pleased to find themselves extensively cited that they did not actually read the submission very carefully — betrayed all sense of academic rigor and standards Astonishingly no one seems to have lost their jobs or positions as a result of this case — academia, ain’t it great!
The above characterizations of concepts are neither definitions nor exhausting presentations of problems related to them. Instead, they are intended to give a short introduction to the contributions below. As Sokal and Bricmont point out, even if the science the so-called thinkers cite were accurate most of the time it still has absolutely nothing to do with what they are actually trying pretending?
On the whole, however, the book is a tough slog. Their sense of humor — admittedly born out of frustration — is also ill-suited to their enterprise and their snide asides do it no service either. Angst vor der Wahrheit: It is worse than books debunking psychic phenomena and the like because whereas psychics address the common man, the thinkers attacked here write in prose?
Similarly the illustrative quotes chosen here are merely those the complete review subjectively believes represent the tenor and judgment of the review as a whole.
Results for Alan-Sokal | Book Depository
The science aspect is of course easy to debunk, and thank god Sokal and Bricmont have done some of that work. Dtv 1 May Language: Hail Sokal and Bricmont for wasting so much of their lives on such a ridiculous but apparently necessary task.
Das Gespenst des Populismus: For those who do not recall it: Be the first to review this item Amazon Bestsellers Rank: That group and the thinkers they have embraced have twisted all debate into the unintellectual, returning it to the level of theological debate where anything can be proposed and propounded as long as the proper terminology and, in the case of theological debate, the reigning deities are invoked.
Amazon Second Chance Pass it on, trade it in, give it a second life. Fashionable Nonsense – Canada. Customers who bought this item also bought. Intellectual Impostures – UK. Comment by the sender of the contribution.
Fighting against privileges in economics or physics is literally the same, but not in metaphorical terms. And yet there is. See our Returns Policy. Sokal and Bricmont go to great lengths to maintain that they are only attacking the weak science of these works, but the inescapable conclusion is that thinkers who are willing to spew such claptrap without a thought for its meaning, and whose only goal is to cow and intimidate their audience through the use of incontestable terminology and concepts are, in fact, charlatans, and that while there might be some value in their charlatanry it is not really something we should look upon kindly.
In our opinion, however, the authors we are investigating are analogies between generally accepted theories from the natural sciences and theories that are too vague to be empirically verifiable e. Radical thought must be embraced — but what the Social Text folk do is neither radical nor is it thought.
Instead of having a good laugh and sending the essay back to Sokal the good folks at Social Text took it seriously and published it. Impostures intellectuelles – France.
If a German edition is specified, the page numbers refer to this edition. If you are a seller for this product, would you like to suggest updates through seller support?
Eleganter Unsinn – die Postmoderne auf dem Prüfstand
This analogy could perhaps contribute to explain relativity theory to a sociologist who is familiar with Latour’s sociology, or to explain Latour’s sociology to a physicist, but what sense should it have in explaining the sociology of Latour to unssinn sociologists on the basis of the analogy to relativity theory?
See all free Kindle reading apps. While there is something to this, and it should be kept in mind, there is no escaping that the selections offered are frightening and horrendous enough to warrant casting anything uttered by these “thinkers” into doubt.